2019 Montana Legislature

Additional Bill Links     PDF (with line numbers)

HOUSE BILL NO. 229

INTRODUCED BY B. HAMLETT

 

A BILL FOR AN ACT ENTITLED: "AN ACT GENERALLY REVISING LAWS TO DISTINGUISH FOSSILS FROM MINERALS; STATING A PURPOSE; DEFINING FOSSILS AND FOSSILIZATION; EXEMPTING FOSSILS FROM TITLE 82, MCA; AND PROVIDING AN IMMEDIATE EFFECTIVE DATE AND A RETROACTIVE APPLICABILITY DATE."

 

     WHEREAS, fossils are part of Montana's history and landscape; and

     WHEREAS, fossils situated upon private lands have customarily been deemed owned by the fee title owner of the land; and

     WHEREAS, in Earl Douglass, 44 Pub. Lands Dec. 325, 1915 WL 1202 (1915), the Department of Interior said clearly that fossil remains of dinosaurs and other prehistoric animals are not minerals within the meaning of the United States mining laws, and lands containing such remains are not subject to entry under such laws; and

     WHEREAS, the court in Hunterfly Realty Corp. v. State of New York, 346 N.Y.S.2d 455 (N.Y.Ct.Cl. 1973) held that mastodon fossils are not considered minerals; and

     WHEREAS, no Montana court or agency, nor any other state or federal court or agency, has ever before defined or construed the term "minerals" in a real property conveyance agreement to include fossils; and

     WHEREAS, no scientific or legal journal, treatise, or other academic writing has ever defined or construed the term "minerals" in a real property conveyance agreement to include fossils; and

     WHEREAS, the U.S. District Court, sitting in diversity jurisdiction and interpreting state law, in the case of Murray v. Billings Garfield Land Company, 187 F.Supp.3d 1203 (D.Mont. 2016), correctly held that the term "minerals" in an instrument is exclusive of fossils; and

     WHEREAS, a three-judge panel of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, sitting in diversity jurisdiction and interpreting state law, incorrectly reversed the U.S. District Court in the case of Murray v. BEJ Minerals, LLC, 908 F.3d 437 (9th Cir. 2018), holding in a 2-1 split decision filed on November 6, 2018, that the term "minerals" in an instrument includes fossils; and

     WHEREAS, the Montana Legislature finds that the two-judge majority opinion abrogates a century of real estate custom and practice in Montana and threatens private property rights; and

     WHEREAS, the Montana Legislature may properly distinguish fossils and minerals by legislation to conform with Montana custom; and

     WHEREAS, the Montana Legislature determines as matters of policy of the State of Montana and preservation of private property rights that the term "minerals" in an instrument does not include fossils.

 

BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF MONTANA:

 

     NEW SECTION.  Section 1.  Purpose. (1) The purpose of [sections 1 through 3] is to enact into law the traditional understanding that fossils are not minerals and that fossils belong to the surface estate, unless conveyed by a clear and express grant.

     (2) It is the intent of the legislature that [sections 1 through 3] apply prospectively and retroactively to the maximum extent possible under the constitutions of the United States and the state of Montana.

 

     NEW SECTION.  Section 2.  Fossils distinguished. (1) When used in any instrument, unless the clear and express terms of the instrument provide otherwise, the term "minerals" does not include fossils.

     (2) For purposes of this section:

     (a) "Fossilized" means to have been preserved by natural processes, including but not limited to:

     (i) burial in accumulated sediment;

     (ii) preservation in ice or amber; and

     (iii) replacement or alteration of organic material or pore spaces in the organic material by minerals or by chemical processes such as permineralization regardless of alteration of the original organic content.

     (b) "Fossils" means any fossilized remains, traces, or imprints of organisms, preserved in or on the earth's crust.

     (3) Fossils are considered part of the surface estate, subject to severance by the fee title owner of the land pursuant to a clear and express grant.

     (4) Fossils are not subject to the provisions of Title 82.

 

     NEW SECTION.  Section 3.  Fossils exempted. Fossils, as defined in [section 2], are not minerals and are exempt from the provisions of this title.

 

     NEW SECTION.  Section 4.  Codification instruction. (1) [Sections 1 and 2] are intended to be codified as an integral part of Title 1, chapter 4, and the provisions of Title 1, chapter 4, apply to [sections 1 and 2].

     (2) [Section 3] is intended to be codified as an integral part of Title 82, and the provisions of Title 82 apply to [section 3].

 

     NEW SECTION.  Section 5. Saving clause. [This act] does not affect penalties that were incurred, or proceedings in federal courts inferior to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals that were begun before [the effective date of this act].

 

     NEW SECTION.  Section 6.  Severability. If a part of [this act] is invalid, all valid parts that are severable from the invalid part remain in effect. If a part of [this act] is invalid in one or more of its applications, the part remains in effect in all valid applications that are severable from the invalid applications.

 

     NEW SECTION.  Section 7.  Effective date. [This act] is effective on passage and approval.

 

     NEW SECTION.  Section 8.  Retroactive applicability. [This act] applies retroactively, within the meaning of 1-2-109, to instruments severing mineral estates from surface estates that do not convey fossils by a clear and express grant.

- END -

 


Latest Version of HB 229 (HB0229.01)
Processed for the Web on January 16, 2019 (8:08pm)

New language in a bill appears underlined, deleted material appears stricken.

Sponsor names are handwritten on introduced bills, hence do not appear on the bill until it is reprinted.

See the status of this bill for the bill's primary sponsor.

 Status of this Bill | 2019 Legislature | Leg. Branch Home
All versions of this bill (PDF format)
Authorized print version of this bill w/line numbers (PDF format)
[
NEW SEARCH ]

Prepared by Montana Legislative Services
(406) 444-3064